Sandro Tonali’s preferred next destination has been revealed amid mounting speculation over his future at Newcastle United, with Liverpool and Arsenal emerging as the primary contenders. TEAMtalk reports that sources close to the player have indicated a clear preference for a move that guarantees regular Champions League football and a higher-profile role, with both Merseyside and north London clubs fitting that criteria. While Newcastle remain determined to keep their midfield linchpin, the 25-year-old Italian’s representatives are monitoring developments closely ahead of the summer window.
Tonali has been one of Newcastle’s most consistent performers since completing his 10-month betting ban in August 2024. He has started 18 of the club’s 23 Premier League matches this season, contributing four goals and three assists while averaging 2.3 tackles, 1.6 interceptions and 88% pass completion per 90 minutes. Under Eddie Howe, who has publicly described him as “one of the best midfielders in the league”, Tonali has formed a formidable partnership with Bruno Guimarães. His contract runs until summer 2028 with an option for an additional year, giving Newcastle substantial leverage and a valuation starting north of £80m for any potential sale.
Liverpool and Arsenal’s Tactical Case
Liverpool see Tonali as the ideal addition to Arne Slot’s midfield engine room, where his ball-winning tenacity, progressive passing and composure under pressure would complement Alexis Mac Allister and Dominik Szoboszlai. The Reds’ high-pressing system demands players who can win duels and transition quickly, areas where Tonali excels. Arsenal’s interest is similarly tactical: Mikel Arteta views him as perfect competition and cover for Declan Rice, with the Italian’s ability to play as a deep-lying playmaker or box-to-box No8 providing versatility in Arteta’s double pivot setup. Both clubs’ Champions League status and higher-profile projects align with Tonali’s reported preference for a step up in competition.
Newcastle’s position remains strong. They are under no immediate financial pressure to sell and view Tonali as central to their long-term ambition of consistent top-four finishes. The club’s ownership continues to back Howe’s vision of building around young, high-potential talents, and Tonali fits that profile perfectly. However, a substantial offer from a Champions League regular — particularly if structured with instalments and add-ons — could test their resolve, especially if the player expresses a desire to move.
Market Reaction and Valuation Dynamics
Betting markets have responded to the latest developments, with odds shortening on Tonali leaving Newcastle this summer. Liverpool and Arsenal are priced closely as joint favourites, while retention at St James’ Park has drifted. The latest Sandro Tonali next club odds reflect growing market belief in a big-money transfer, though Newcastle’s high valuation continues to act as a deterrent. Any deal would likely require a club-record fee for either Liverpool or Arsenal, making it one of the summer’s marquee midfield moves.
Tonali’s post-ban resurgence has reaffirmed his status as one of Europe’s most complete midfielders. His work rate, passing range and leadership qualities make him a valuable asset in any top-tier system. For Newcastle, retaining him supports their project; for Liverpool and Arsenal, he represents a high-impact addition with resale potential. The agent’s upcoming talks with Newcastle will likely serve as an early positioning exercise, but the summer window promises to be decisive for one of the Premier League’s standout midfield talents.
Summer Crossroads and Midfield Market Context
The coming months represent a pivotal period for Tonali. Stay and cement his legacy at Newcastle; move to Liverpool and join a high-pressing title contender; or join Arsenal and become part of Arteta’s long-term vision. Newcastle will aim to tie him down to improved terms or at least secure clarity before the window opens. With no pressing need to move and multiple high-profile suitors, his future remains one of the defining midfield narratives of the summer, balancing loyalty, ambition and financial strategy.