Manchester United are grappling with a £60m question over whether to pursue Brighton midfielder Carlos Baleba this summer, according to the Manchester Evening News. The 21-year-old Cameroon international has emerged as one of the Premier League’s most promising young defensive midfielders, but committing a fee of that magnitude raises significant strategic and financial considerations for United’s planned midfield overhaul under a new manager. Brighton have made it clear they will not entertain offers below £60m for Baleba, viewing him as a cornerstone of their project.
Baleba has started 19 of Brighton's 23 Premier League matches this season under Fabian Hürzeler, averaging 2.4 tackles, 1.8 interceptions and 85% pass completion per 90 minutes while demonstrating excellent ability to break lines with forward passes. His composure on the ball and physical presence have made him a key component of Brighton's possession-based style, drawing comparisons to a young N'Golo Kanté with superior technical quality. At 21, he offers significant resale value and the potential to develop into a world-class midfielder, making him an attractive proposition for clubs looking to invest in youth.
United's Midfield Puzzle and Baleba Fit
United's interest reflects ongoing concerns over midfield depth and dynamism. Casemiro's influence has waned due to age and mobility issues, while the supporting cast has lacked consistent energy in certain matches. Kobbie Mainoo has been a bright spot, but Carricks preferred double pivot system demands athletic, ball-winning players who can also progress possession — areas where Baleba excels. His left-footedness would offer balance alongside right-footed options, and his youth allows United to build around him for the next decade. However, the £60m+ price tag represents a significant outlay, particularly when weighed against other priorities such as defensive reinforcement and attacking creativity.
The £60m question is not just financial but tactical and strategic. United must decide whether Baleba is the right profile to commit such funds to, or whether resources would be better allocated elsewhere — such as a proven No6 or additional wide options. Brighton’s firm stance adds complexity: they are under no pressure to sell and would only consider offers that reflect Baleba’s rising stock and contract until 2028. United’s financial position allows them to meet the valuation, particularly if they generate funds through player sales, but the decision requires careful balancing of immediate needs and long-term planning.
Market Reaction and Valuation Pressure
Betting markets have shown mild movement in response to the reports, with odds shortening slightly on Baleba leaving Brighton this summer. Manchester United are prominent among potential suitors, though retention at the Amex remains the market favourite. The latest Carlos Baleba next club odds reflect growing chatter, but Brighton’s £60m+ valuation continues to act as a significant barrier. A deal at that level would represent one of the summer’s most ambitious midfield transfers and signal United’s intent to invest heavily in youth and athleticism.
Baleba’s rapid rise has been remarkable: from Lille to Brighton, he has transitioned seamlessly to the Premier League while maintaining his physical edge and technical quality. United’s pursuit, if serious, would be a statement of ambition and long-term planning. For Brighton, a sale would provide significant profit and funds to reinvest in other areas. The summer window will test both clubs’ resolve, with Baleba’s next move likely to be one of the defining midfield transfers of the window.
Summer Outlook and Midfield Market Context
The £60m question will dominate United’s summer planning. Commit to Baleba and secure a high-upside talent who can grow into a world-class midfielder; allocate resources elsewhere and risk missing out on one of the division’s brightest prospects. Brighton will demand a premium for a player who has already proven himself in the Premier League and offers substantial upside. United’s decision will reflect their recruitment philosophy under Amorim: prioritise youth and athleticism, or seek more immediate impact. Baleba’s future remains one of the key midfield narratives of the window, balancing financial prudence with sporting ambition.